
Illustration by Ethan Brown
Note: For illustrative purposes only; actual details may vary
Cahokia Mounds State Historic Site
Overview
Cahokia Mounds State Historic Site (formerly Park) is the site of a major prehistoric city where various Indigenous Peoples resided, potentially including people who today would broadly be called Two-Spirit.
The park later became a popular cruising ground for men from at least the 1960s into the 1990s.
Click images to enlarge and see captions.
History
The 2,200-acre Cahokia Mounds State Historic Site, located between the present-day cities of Collinsville and East St. Louis, Illinois, preserves the remains of the largest and most sophisticated prehistoric Indigenous civilization north of Mexico. First inhabited in the ninth century by Indigenous peoples of the Late Woodland period, various Mississippian Peoples from c. 1050–1350 developed the site into a sprawling, diverse city that at its peak featured about 120 earthworks and supported a population of up to 20,000 residents. Following its gradual abandonment, people of the Oneota culture settled nearby in the 15th century. The mounds were later named for the Cahokia People, an Illiniwek (or Illinois) group who resided there in the 17th century until French colonial settlers and, later, Americans laid claim to the land. The site became an Illinois State Park in 1923 and a National Historic Landmark in 1964, then it was listed on the National Register in 1966 and designated a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1982.
Although stymied by European and American colonists’ systematic repression of Indigenous cultural traditions, many Indigenous Peoples have for centuries embraced sexual diversity, recognized multiple genders, and exhibited a fluid understanding of gender roles and expression. Some Indigenous cultures even held special reverence for gender-variant members, who often act as healers, medicine people, or ceremonial leaders. Most Indigenous Peoples have terms in their languages to articulate their specific understandings of sexuality and gender. Since 1990, some have adopted the pan-tribal terms “Two-Spirit” and “Indigiqueer” to replace the derogatory term “berdache,” which French colonists in the 17th century and anthropologists thereafter broadly applied to any Indigenous person who did not conform to Western gender or sexuality norms. While archaeologists and historians have not yet found direct evidence of Two-Spirit people at Cahokia, Two-Spirit people are known to have existed among many of the Peoples who inhabited the site—and their modern descendants—including the Caddo, Chickasaw, Illinois, Natchez, and Osage cultures.
As early as the 1960s, Cahokia Mounds became a known outdoor cruising area where men could meet each other, find sexual partners to take home, or have clandestine public sex. The park was listed in gay travel guides from the 1960s into the 1990s. Danny Ryan, who had lived and operated a shoe store on the park grounds at 4 Ramey Street (demolished) with wife Prudence from about 1960 until it was seized and demolished in 1989, nicknamed the site access road and picnic shelters as “Gaytown” due to the prevalence of men cruising there.
Cruising parks, beaches, plazas, restrooms, and other public spaces has long been a feature of gay and bisexual life. Public cruising remained popular among men who have sex with men (MSM) in Illinois even after the state, in 1961, became the first in the country to decriminalize consensual sodomy between adults. According to Chicago-based lawyer Edward Mogul, who for decades represented MSM arrested for public indecency while cruising, its continued popularity was partly due to the comparatively higher risk of frequenting gay bars. Police continued to regularly raid gay bars, which carried damaging consequences for those arrested:
“If you were caught in one of the raids, your name and address were published in the newspaper; many lives were ruined. It was safer for guys to go looking for sex in public places than it was to be in the bars.”
— Edward Mogul, 2013
Parks like Cahokia Mounds provided more anonymity and security for MSM. As opposed to commercial establishments catering to gay men, parks are large public spaces open to all and intended for aimless recreation, providing a natural cover for anonymous socializing between two men. Parks were, therefore, typically not policed as frequently or effectively as gay bars. Nevertheless, police entrapment and arrests for cruising in parks still occurred and, similar to bar raids, often resulted in public shaming in the newspaper.
The vague wording of public indecency laws left the definition of “lewd” or “indecent” open to interpretation by individual police officers and susceptible to misuse and perjury. Some men cruised parks merely in search of partners to take home but a perjurer victimized them and charged them with public indecency. In addition to being targeted by police, men also faced the danger of anti-LGBTQ hate crimes while cruising. At Cahokia, for example, a man posed as a fellow cruiser before robbing others.
In the 1980s, in anticipation of surging tourism to Cahokia Mounds following its designation as a World Heritage Site in 1982 and the opening of a museum in 1989, park management and police cracked down on gay activity. Management installed gates on the access roads and closed the picnic areas frequented by cruisers, while police began sending male officers to entrap men. Those displaced from Cahokia Mounds relocated to other nearby parks, including the northeast shore of the lake in Horseshoe Lake State Park and the Lewis and Clark State Historic Site along the Mississippi River.
Sources
“Cahokia Mounds to Dig Up Tourism Dollars,” Belleville News-Democrat (Belleville, IL), June 26, 1988, 1B-2B.
“Crackdown On Homosexuals At Park; Minister Charged,” St. Louis Post-Dispatch, July 13, 1982, 3A.
David Gosnell, “Police Patrol Parks For Solicitors of Sex,” Belleville News-Democrat, October 31, 1989, 3B, 5B.
George Chauncey, “Privacy Could Only Be Had in Public: Forging a Gay World in the Streets,” in Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World, 1890-1940 (New York: Basic Books, 1994): 179-205.
Matt Simonette, “When Cruising Goes Bad: The Private Aspects of Public Indecency,” Windy City Times, May 8, 2013, bit.ly/4ons1Bq. [source of pull quote]
Raymond E. Hauser, “The Berdache and the Illinois Indian Tribe during the Last Half of the Seventeenth Century,” Ethnohistory 37, no. 1 (Winter 1990), 45-65.