
Illustration by Ethan Brown
Note: For illustrative purposes only; actual details may vary
La Fonda
Overview
The public spaces of La Fonda, an expansive hotel on Santa Fe Plaza, served as a popular gathering place and cruising locale for 2SLGBTQ people, likely since its opening in 1922.
Many prominent 2SLGBTQ figures also stayed at La Fonda as guests, including writers Willa Cather and Patricia Highsmith, and actor George Maharis, who filmed episodes of the Route 66 television series while there.
Click images to enlarge and see captions.
History
La Fonda (Spanish for “the Inn”), a rambling Spanish-Pueblo Revival-style hotel at the southeast corner of Santa Fe Plaza, opened in 1922 on a site occupied by a series of inns since the early 17th century. The Santa Fe Railway purchased the hotel in 1925, then leased it to the Fred Harvey Company in 1926. Following an extensive redesign and expansion, the Company operated La Fonda as a Harvey House until 1968, after which private owners continued to operate it as a hotel.
La Fonda became a central gathering place for tourists and residents alike — and particularly for those involved in Santa Fe’s arts colony, which included many 2SLGBTQ individuals. Prominent figures known to have frequented La Fonda included Walter Willard “Spud” Johnson, writer and publisher of the literary magazine The Laughing Horse (1922-1939); artist Georgia O’Keeffe; memoirist and patron of the arts Mabel Dodge Luhan; photographer Carl Van Vechten; poets and partners Robert Hunt and Witter Bynner; and writer Lynn Riggs, who premiered his early avant-garde documentary A Day in Santa Fe (1931) in a guest room there.
For years until about 1950, a group of lesbians, including novelist and social worker Marian Winnek, rode in on horseback and lunched at the same table every day at La Fonda. According to a local resident, they wore “mannish clothes and big hats” and “seemed to want everybody to look at them” in contrast to the more discreet gay male patrons. La Fonda’s role as a safe space for 2SLGBTQ individuals to gather continued for decades, bolstered by its listing in LGBTQ travel guides published in the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s. Memoirist Walter Cooper, who moved to Santa Fe in 1973, emphasized that the hotel’s “U-shaped bar was the primary watering hole and meeting ground for Santa Fe’s gay crowd.”
La Fonda was also a noted cruising locale for gay men seeking clandestine sexual encounters, which was documented as early as 1934. Walter Willard “Spud” Johnson wrote in his journal that year that he met a man while cruising the basement restrooms and proceeded to have sex with him in the lobby. Later, travel guides listed La Fonda’s lobby, bar, and restrooms as cruising sites, with some guides also noting opportunities for outdoor cruising by walking the block surrounding the hotel. By the 1970s, the restrooms had become a “notorious lavender landmark,” according to Cooper, who recalled the “dingy green restroom walls…scribbled with sexual graffiti, phone numbers…, and rude remarks about some of the town’s eminent citizens.” In The Gay Insider USA (1972), John Paul Hudson deemed it “the cruisiest tearoom between the first truck stop west of Topeka [Kansas] and Los Angeles.” The hotel bar, Hudson added, was “cruisy as can be — for an integrated bar,” becoming especially packed with “males elbow-to-elbow” during the Fiestas de Santa Fe.
La Fonda’s popularity among LGBTQ crowds waned in the 1980s as more establishments specifically catering to an LGBTQ clientele opened in Santa Fe. Additionally, hotel management actively sought to deter gay cruising activity there. They repaired the infamous restrooms, eventually demolishing them entirely and installing a smaller men’s room upstairs within the purview of the bartenders (however, some men reportedly circumvented this by instead going to the rooftop).
Throughout La Fonda’s history, it accommodated many notable 2SLGBTQ figures visiting Santa Fe:
Willa Cather, writer, and her life partner, editor Edith Lewis, stayed at La Fonda in 1925 and 1926, during which they worked on the manuscript for Cather’s widely acclaimed novel Death Comes for the Archbishop (1927). For the book, Cather took inspiration from the Cathedral Basilica of St. Francis of Assisi located opposite La Fonda.
William S. Burroughs, seminal writer of the Beat Generation, repeatedly stayed at La Fonda while a student at the all-male Los Alamos Ranch School from 1929 to 1932, staying at times with a group of other students and at others with school Director Albert J. Connell on his twice-weekly excursions to Santa Fe. Burroughs struggled with his homosexuality during this time and, partially out of shame, began writing an ultimately unfinished novel on La Fonda stationery.
Simone de Beauvoir, openly bisexual philosopher and feminist, visited La Fonda in 1947 with one of her lovers, Natalie “Natasha” Sorokin, during a four-month journey across the United States. De Beauvoir documented the journey in a diary, L’Amerique au jour de jour (America Day by Day), in which she wrote, “La Fonda is the most beautiful hotel in America, perhaps the most beautiful I’ve ever seen in my life.”
Patricia Highsmith, writer of psychological thriller novels, possibly began writing one of her most widely acclaimed novels, The Talented Mr. Ripley (1955), while staying at La Fonda with her lover, sociologist and humanitarian worker Ellen Blumenthal Hill. The hotel is also featured in Highsmith’s debut novel, Strangers on a Train (1950).
George Maharis, singer and Emmy-nominated co-star of the hit television series Route 66 (1960-1964), stayed at La Fonda for three weeks in 1960 while filming there and throughout northern New Mexico for episodes 26 and 27 of the show’s first season. The series was filmed entirely on location throughout the country, but Santa Fe was one of the few filming locations actually along Route 66 (others include Los Angeles and Needles, California). Episode 26 included scenes filmed at La Fonda. According to a TV Guide article, Maharis spent most of his time at the hotel and, other than filming, avoided group activities. Maharis left the series in 1963 amid a mix of severe health issues, contract disputes, and — it was later purported — behind-the-scenes tension over his sexuality. Later, in 1967 and 1974, Maharis was arrested in Los Angeles for cruising for sex in men’s bathrooms.
John Paul Hudson (pseudonym John Francis Hunter), writer, actor, and gay rights activist, stayed at La Fonda for extended periods in 1971 during filming of the Western film Greaser’s Palace (1972) and to conduct research for his comprehensive LGBTQ travel guide, The Gay Insider USA (1972), which included La Fonda.
Additional 2SLGBTQ guests at La Fonda have included First Lady and activist Eleanor Roosevelt and playwright Thornton Wilder.
Sources
Anita Gates and Alex Traub, “George Maharis, TV Heartthrob of ‘Route 66,’ Is Dead at 94,” New York Times, May 28, 2023, nyti.ms/4dmodw9.
Carl Van Vechten, The Splendid Drunken Twenties: Selections from the Daybooks, 1922–1930, ed. Bruce Kellner (University of Illinois Press, 2003).
Dan Jenkins, “Talk About Putting the Show on the Road!” TV Guide (July 22-28, 1961), 12-16, bit.ly/4rSiwMw.
David Steinberg, “Hotel Closes Nightclub After Paying $500 Fine,” Albuquerque Journal, October 8, 1980, 44.
“George Maharis page,” Queer Music Heritage (blog), bit.ly/4hoXMZ2.
“History of La Fonda on the Plaza,” Historic Hotels of America (National Trust for Historic Preservation), bit.ly/4APeQ1X.
James H. Cox, “The Cross and the Harvest Dance: Lynn Riggs’ and James Hughes’ A Day in Santa Fe,” in Quarterly Review of Film and Video 32, no. 4 (2015): 384-398.
John Francis Hunter [John Paul Hudson], The Gay Insider USA (Stonehill Publishing Company, 1972).
Jordan Biro Walters, Wide-Open Desert: A Queer History of New Mexico (University of Washington Press, 2023).
“La Fonda on the Plaza: 100 Years of Hospitality,” (2023), PBS, video series.
Richard Melzer, Fred Harvey Houses of the Southwest (Arcadia Publishing, 2008).
Simone de Beauvoir, America Day by Day [1954], trans. Carol Cosman (University of California Press, 1999).
Ted Morgan, Literary Outlaw: The Life and Times of William S. Burroughs (Henry Holt and Company, 1988).
Walter Cooper, Unbuttoned: Gay Life in the Santa Fe Arts Scene: A Memoir (self-published, CreateSpace, 2016).