
Illustration by Ethan Brown
Note: For illustrative purposes only; actual details may vary
My Place (aka My Place Disco, My Place Tavern, or My Place Lounge)
Overview
Bloomington’s first openly gay bar, a gay-owned discotheque called My Place, operated on the combined ground floor of these two Main Street commercial buildings from 1979 to 1982.
The bar served as a vital space for local LGBTQ residents to socialize and build community, although its history also illustrates the hostility that openly queer spaces faced at the time.
Click images to enlarge and see captions.
History
In 1979, former hairstylist William Peden and an unidentified co-owner (possibly Peden’s romantic partner, Lee Marburger) opened what is considered the first openly gay bar in the small city of Bloomington, Illinois. Peden, who had recently moved to the area, saw a need for a gay bar in Bloomington since the nearest gay bars were miles away in Peoria, Champaign, or Springfield. Peden purchased a former western music bar called My Place, which David Johnson and James Rice had opened in 1977 in a former Chinese restaurant, and spent $30,000 to redecorate the interior and install disco lighting and a sound system.
To the owners’ surprise, they easily secured a liquor license and passed inspections without any discriminatory treatment, despite about a dozen complaints to Bloomington Mayor Rich Buchanan. Those complaints “ranged in tone from moderate objections to the ‘how-dare-you-let-this-happen-here’ variety,” according to the local underground newspaper, the Post-Amerikan. As paraphrased in the Post-Amerikan, Mayor Buchanan was not seeking to prevent a gay-oriented establishment like My Place from opening, because “he wouldn’t want to live in a city where the mayor or the police chief or even a dozen citizens could decide that some people have rights that others do not.”
However, the bar still endured occasional anti-LGBTQ hostility. Just within the week following the announcement of the openly gay bar’s opening in The Pantagraph—Bloomington-Normal’s newspaper of record—there were at least two acts of vandalism at the bar. First, a vandal compromised the roof’s structural integrity by pulling down a supporting beam using a chain attached to their vehicle. Three days later, another vandal damaged the front door with a hammer. Over the next few years, the bar continued to face some hostility: Peden’s car was vandalized, the building’s windows were broken, eggs were thrown at the building, and slurs were shouted at exiting patrons.
The bar’s “opening night was a smashing success” that felt, to Post-Amerikan columnist on LGBTQ topics Ferdydurke (pseudonym), “unique and historic”:
“[The owners] hadn’t been absolutely sure that the gay people of this community would be able to overcome their fears and freely patronize a gay establishment. That we have is what makes the opening of My Place a historic event.”
Ferdydurke, Post-Amerikan columnist, 1979
From its opening, the bar was an important space for local LGBTQ people to gather, socialize, and forge community. However, not all local LGBTQ residents felt comfortable patronizing an openly gay establishment in socially conservative Bloomington. In The Pantagraph’s 1982 feature about local LGBTQ life, a lesbian woman who was not open about her sexuality at work noted that she never visited My Place specifically because she was afraid one of her coworkers might see her. As a result of intense paranoia about the possibility of coworkers, friends, or family members seeing them entering a gay establishment, LGBTQ people in communities like Bloomington-Normal instead traveled to gay bars in nearby cities.
In April 1981, Gerald “Jerry” Warren purchased My Place from Peden and undertook multiple interior renovations to make the space “look like a bar for once, and not a restaurant” (it still retained most of the finishes from the Chinese restaurant that previously occupied the space in the early 1970s). Beginning in November, My Place started hosting a gay coffeehouse called Your Place. On Friday evenings from 6:00 to 9:00 pm, Warren turned the music down and the lights up, and served coffee and tea instead of alcoholic beverages. Ferdydurke reported on the coffeehouse in the Post-Amerikan:
“The idea was to give lesbians and gay men of the community a place to meet and get acquainted—but something different from the standard gay bar scene.…The coffeehouse provides a space for conversation, a chance to build support and exchange ideas.”
Ferdydurke, Post-Amerikan columnist, 1982
As opposed to the bar scene’s typical focus on drinking, dancing, and finding sexual partners, Your Place offered a quieter atmosphere where patrons could play games, converse more easily, and plan anything from a Sunday brunch to a bowling team to a discussion group. It continued to operate until the bar closed in early 1982 following multiple fines and liquor license suspensions.
Following the closure of My Place, partners Dan Cochran and Mark Mears opened a restaurant called Twylla’s Place, at 523 North Main Street, which briefly served as Bloomington’s queer space from November 1983 until April 1984. However, a Valentine’s Day newspaper ad calling it “the only gay bar in town” set off a series of charges alleging the owners were violating liquor ordinances and were purely interested in operating a bar rather than a restaurant. Cochran and Mears ultimately closed the bar and left Bloomington.
In the 1980s, Peden also repeatedly attempted to secure liquor licenses for gay bars at various locations in Bloomington. He and other bar owners, however, were stymied by urban renewal efforts often targeting bars, by the “unofficial moratorium on new liquor licenses in the downtown area,” and by the Illinois Dram Shop Act, which prohibited the sale of alcohol within 100 feet of a church (two religious meeting spaces had opened in the 1980s at 416 North Main Street and 105 West Monroe Street). Bloomington went without a queer space until 1993, when The Bistro opened at 316 North Main Street.
Sources
Deborah Wiatt, “Not ‘My Place,’ Our Place,” The Post-Amerikan 10, no 2 (May 1981), 11.
“Discotheque to Open for Gay Community,” The Pantagraph (Bloomington-Normal, Illinois), March 30, 1979, A3.
Elaine Graybill, “The Gay Life,” The Pantagraph (Bloomington-Normal, Illinois), June 13, 1982, D1, D5.
Emilie Krebs, “Church Issue Keys Bar Ban,” The Pantagraph (Bloomington-Normal, Illinois), October 25, 1983, A2.
Ferdydurke [pseudonym], “Gay Bar Opens in Bloomington-Normal: City Not Destroyed,” The Post-Amerikan 8, no.1 (May 1979): 13. [source of first pull quote]
Ferdydurke [pseudonym], “‘Your Place’ Offers Friends, Fun,” The Post-Amerikan 10, no. 8 (January 1982), 11. [source of second pull quote]
Karmine Beecroft, “Radical Roots and Enduring Activism: Milestones in LGBTQIA+ History at Illinois State University,” Illinois State University, June 30, 2025, bit.ly/3T4FgeI.
“Main Street Building Hit for Second Time,” The Pantagraph (Bloomington-Normal, Illinois), April 4, 1979, A11.
Micaela Harris, Emily McCusker, and Maria Mears (McLean County Museum of History), “Gay Places Struggled, Thrived Downtown,” The Pantagraph, bit.ly/4w5rbfP.