
Illustration by Ethan Brown
Note: For illustrative purposes only; actual details may vary
Smokey’s Den II
Overview
Smokey’s Den, the first openly gay and lesbian bar in Springfield, Illinois, relocated from its since-demolished building on North 5th Street to this building in 1980.
Mary Lou “Smokey” Schneider operated Smokey’s Den here until retiring and closing the bar in 2003.
Click images to enlarge and see captions.
History
In October 1966, Mary Lou “Smokey” Schneider (1928-2015) opened Smokey’s Den at 127 North 5th Street (demolished) in downtown Springfield, Illinois. The bar took its name from the nickname that Schneider, an amateur softball player inducted into the USA Softball of Illinois Hall of Fame, earned while playing for the Springfield Merchantettes in the 1950s.
Prior to Smokey’s, gay travel guides listed two bars in Springfield. These bars, however, differed from the lesbian-owned Smokey’s Den, which was opened specifically as a gay and lesbian bar. Conversely, Two Brothers Lounge, located at 309 East Monroe Street, had a mixed clientele with a heavy military patronage. Helen’s Gee-I Tavern, located at 212 North 5th Street (demolished), was a closed-door bar that “made it possible for persons known in the community to get together without being hassled” but “made it difficult for a new person coming out to become a part of the community.” Their contrast with Smokey’s is further evidenced by Schneider’s emphatic response to John Paul Hudson (pseudonym John Francis Hunter) regarding the inclusion of Smokey’s in The Gay Insider USA:
“We at Smokey’s Den are a very happy group. We welcome all gays regardless of color, creed, or what have you. . . . My bar is a place to come to after your day’s work is done. You can relax and be yourself, without hiding anything. . . . You ask if I wish to be listed. The answer is YES, because some of the most beautiful people in the world walk through my doors, and I welcome more to share them.”
— Mary Lou “Smokey” Schneider, 1972
Smokey’s permitted dancing between same-sex partners and, beginning in 1967, hosted shows by female impersonators (the term then used), including the popular in-house troupe the Smokettes.
To avoid the police harassment that many gay and lesbian bars faced at the time, Schneider actively cultivated relationships with local law enforcement and ensured the bar remained a respectable establishment free of recreational drug use and altercations between patrons. She recalled, however, that prior to establishing those relationships,
“when the police would come into the bar, the kids would yell, ‘switch’ because the boys were dancing with boys and then the boys would grab a girl. Then one night [the police] came in and somebody yelled ‘switch’ and all of the sudden [the officer] took his nightstick and slid it down to the floor and said, ‘Carry on, kids.’ And we did ever since.”
— Mary Lou “Smokey” Schneider, interview with Vital Voice, 2012
Other bars along North 5th Street in the late 1960s and 1970s also welcomed, or at least tolerated, LGBTQ people. These included The Alibi at No. 200 (demolished), Orpheum Lounge at No. 208 (demolished), and Tropical Isle at No. 400. With bars and taverns vulnerable to downtown “clean up” and redevelopment efforts, much of this small nightlife district was razed to make way for such projects as Illinois National Bank’s new building in 1972, the Near North Village housing complex in 1980, and the creation of Union Square Park in 1986.
Schneider opened a second bar called Smokey’s “Nu” Den at 3003 Mayden Avenue (demolished), which operated from 1975 until about 1979. The following year, in April 1980, Smokey’s Den relocated from its original 5th Street building to a larger space around the corner at 411 East Washington Street. Over the next two decades, Smokey’s II remained one of the few LGBTQ bars in Springfield. Others included the Robert Satterlee-owned Saloon at 2801 North Peoria Road and Bobby’s A Dance Bar at 3036 North Peoria Road, as well as The Station House at 306 East Washington Street (demolished), which helped reinforce East Washington Street’s “reputation as the place where many Springfield gay men and lesbian women go to socialize.”
In the early 1990s, Springfield saw a noted increase in instances of physical assault and vandalism targeting LGBTQ people. Neo-Nazi skinheads repeatedly attacked patrons of Smokey’s, Station House, and New Dimensions while they were entering their vehicles, which the perpetrators also vandalized. At the same time, it remained legal — until amendment of the Illinois Human Rights Act in 2006 — to discriminate against LGBTQ people in Springfield. As such, Ollie’s Saloon, a nearby bar at 300 East Washington Street (demolished), continued to openly discriminate against LGBTQ people in the 1990s. The bar’s exterior sign declared it “A Straight Bar,” and owner-operator Ollie Thomas enacted a policy of removing any patron that “looked” or acted LGBTQ. As this climate of open discrimination endured, Smokey’s Den remained a vital safe space even into the 1990s.
In 1999, Schneider announced her retirement and the sale of the bar in an ad in Prairie Flame, the Springfield-based newspaper founded by activist Buff Carmichael in 1996 to serve the Downstate Illinois LGBTQ community. However, the sale fell through, and she went on to operate the bar until retiring and closing Smokey’s in 2003. Upon Schneider’s death in 2015, the community hosted a memorial and celebration of her life in the space formerly occupied by Smokey’s. One attendee succinctly articulated the impact she had locally: “She made a place for us when there was no place for us.”
Sources
Bill Steinbacher-Kemp, “Springfield Gays Say They Are Targets of Skinhead Violence,” Illinois Times, July 16, 1992, 7-8.
Gaylife Magazine, no. 5 (1979), 43.
Jodi Woodard, “Remembering the Late Mary Lou Smokey Schneider,” The State Journal-Register (Springfield, Illinois), January 31, 2015, 9.
John Francis Hunter [John Paul Hudson], The Gay Insider USA (Stonehill Publishing Company, 1972), 356-57. [source of pull quote]
Martha Miller, “Growing Old Gay: Life in Springfield for All These Years,” Illinois Times, May 16, 2024, bit.ly/4j0GIt1.
Martha Miller and Buff Carmichael, “Raising a Last Toast to Smokey, Friend of Gay Springfield,” Illinois Times, January 29, 2015, bit.ly/3VbfFSH.
Michael P. Burk, “Gay Lib in Springfield,” The Phoenix (Springfield, Illinois), May 23, 1972, 3.
Ron Ebest, “Homosexuals Call for ‘Better Understanding,’” The State Journal-Register (Springfield, Illinois), October 17, 1980, 3.
Sangamon County Historical Society, “Smokey’s Den,” SangamonLink, January 30, 2015, bit.ly/4C2OElc.
“Smokey’s Den to Move,” The State Journal-Register (Springfield, Illinois), April 16, 1980, 28.
“Smokey’s Den Celebrates 32 Years,” Prairie Flame 3, no. 4 (November 1998), 5.
“Springfield’s Smokey’s Den,” Vital Voice, July 31, 2011, archived January 5, 2015, bit.ly/3Xd7DJB.
Tim Landis, “Pioneer in Tolerance: Owner of Smokey’s Den Gets Out of the Tavern Business,” The State Journal-Register (Springfield, Illinois), March 5, 2003, 1, 4.
Wendy Stasell, “Entrance Barred: A Downtown Bar Discriminates Against Gays and Lesbians—And It’s Legal,” Illinois Times, September 9, 1993, 5.