
Illustration by Ethan Brown
Note: For illustrative purposes only; actual details may vary
We’wha & Fort Wingate
Overview
In about 1879, the Zuni potter, weaver, and cultural ambassador We’wha worked at the United States Army’s Fort Wingate and then spent a month in jail there in 1893 following a historic attempt to combat US soldiers’ encroachment on Zuni sovereignty.
We’wha was a lhamana, the Zuni term for a male-bodied person who adopts traditionally feminine roles and attire, which might today be classified as Two-Spirit.
Click images to enlarge and see captions.
History
Although stymied by European and American colonists’ systematic repression of Indigenous cultural traditions, many Indigenous Peoples have for centuries embraced sexual diversity, recognized multiple genders, and exhibited a fluid understanding of gender roles and expressions. Some Indigenous cultures even hold special reverence for gender-variant members, who often serve as healers, medicine people, or ceremonial leaders. Most Indigenous Peoples have terms in their languages to articulate their specific understandings of sexuality and gender, although French colonists in the 17th century and anthropologists thereafter broadly used the derogatory term berdache to describe Indigenous people who did not conform to Western gender or sexuality norms. Since 1990, many Indigenous people have used the pan-tribal general terms “Two-Spirit” or “Indigiqueer.”
The Zuni (or ‘A:shiwi) people, a historically isolated community of Pueblo Indians in present-day Arizona and New Mexico, had well-defined traditional roles for men and women but, according to anthropologist Will Roscoe, “viewed gender as an acquired rather than an inborn trait” and embraced more than two genders. They use the term lhamana to describe a male-bodied person who adopts traditionally feminine roles and attire. Known lhamana have included Manna, Tsalatitsa, U’k, Kwiwishdi, and Kasinelu. The most famous was We’wha (c. 1849–1896; variously spelled), a potter, weaver, and cultural ambassador who resided in the ancient Zuni Pueblo, located about 30 miles south of present-day Gallup, New Mexico.1Considering that both he/him and she/her pronouns were used for We’wha and other lhamana and that the English language’s rigid gender pronouns do not fully capture Indigenous cultures’ complex understandings of gender, they/them pronouns are used for We’wha hereafter.
When We’wha was an infant, both their parents died of smallpox brought by white settlers. Their adoptive family, considered among the wealthiest in Zuni, lived in a multi-room apartment at the northwest corner of the pueblo’s main block. The apartment also housed the ceremonial chamber of a Zuni medicine order called lhewe:kwe (“Sword People”), through which We’wha acquired ceremonial knowledge from a young age. Throughout life, We’wha performed a mixture of roles traditionally considered feminine — household management, pottery — and masculine — weaving, farming — leading Roscoe to conclude that
“We’wha was not crossing genders, but bridging or combining the social roles of men and women…in terms of religion,…economic roles,…[and] kinship roles.”
— Will Roscoe, 1988
In 1879, We’wha befriended anthropologist Matilda Coxe Stevenson during the first of her many expeditions to Zuni with the US Bureau of American Ethnology. We’wha began to wash clothes for Stevenson and other expedition members, and then for the captains’ families at nearby Fort Wingate — which the US Army had established following its invasion of Mexico in 1846-48 and moved near Gallup in 1868. Stevenson later wrote, after eventually learning in the 1890s that We’wha was a lhamana, about We’wha’s laundering skills:
“This man ultimately became as celebrated as a Chinese laundryman, his own cleanly apparel being his advertising card, and was called upon not only by the officers’ families at the garrison, but by the white settlers near and far.”
— Matilda Coxe Stevenson, 1902
“Only a few work for the whites,” she concluded, “the men wearing female attire being preferred to the women on account of their strength and endurance.” With the assistance of Stevenson, We’wha also became a cultural ambassador for the Zuni due to their English proficiency, expertise in various traditional crafts, and “command of Zuni religious knowledge and practice, having mastered the dual skills of letter-perfect memorization required for learning esoteric material and extemporaneous improvisation employed in relating tales and stories.” Stevenson commissioned pottery from We’wha as artifacts — some of which are now in the collection of the Art Institute of Chicago — and then took We’wha to Washington, DC for a widely publicized six-month-long visit that culminated in a meeting with President Grover Cleveland.
In the 1890s, the US government gradually shifted its Indigenous policy from one of physical removal and extermination to one of forced assimilation and cultural erasure. The US pursued these objectives through the criminalization of Indigenous cultural practices, the indoctrination and abuse of Indigenous children at boarding schools, and the theft and redistribution of Indigenous lands. This included, according to Roscoe, “attempts by the government to alter the values and practices of the Zunis regarding sexuality and gender.” In 1892, Indian Agent John H. Robertson of the Pueblo and Jicarilla Agency wrote to Mary Dissette, a teacher at the Presbyterian missionary school in Zuni who had complained to Robertson that only lhamana — whom she disparagingly called “unsexed mysterious creatures” — would do her laundry:
“It is going to be quite a task to do away with their custom of the men wearing female dress, but I have made up my mind to make an effort to do so.”
— John H. Robertson, 1894
We’wha, whose “self-assurance and independence stood out from both men and women,” was at the forefront of various confrontations in which the Zuni resisted US interference. Most notably, in December 1892, We’wha defiantly prevented US soldiers from entering Zuni Governor Dick Tsanahe’s home to arrest him. The Zuni government accused a Zuni man named Nick Dumaka (or Tumaca) of witchcraft based on his drunken confession and mounting suspicion regarding his rejection of Zuni religion. When Captain Colon Augur and Deputy Marshal Green of Fort Wingate arrived to free Dumaka and arrest Governor Tsanahe, We’wha blocked the door.
Augur then deployed 25 soldiers on standby outside the Pueblo, leading to a tense situation reminiscent of the 1890 Wounded Knee Massacre in North Dakota. The cautious Zuni members armed themselves, forcing the US troops to withdraw. However, tensions escalated days later when the entire Fort Wingate command of nearly 200 soldiers deployed to Zuni. They arrested Governor Tsanahe, in addition to We’wha and the leading bow priest, Nayuchi. According to Zuni accounts, We’wha was imprisoned at Fort Wingate for a month and then returned to the Zuni Pueblo by foot via a nearly 50-mile route along the Continental Divide.
A fire in 1896 demolished most of the 19th-century buildings at Fort Wingate.
Sources
Ethan Brown, “WeWah & BarCheeAmpe at the American Indian Community House,” NYC LGBTQ Historic Sites Project, November 2022, bit.ly/44J77BC.
Harold L. James, “The History of Fort Wingate,” in New Mexico Geological Society Eighteenth Field Conference, 151-158.
John H. Robertson, letter to Mary Dissette, August 19, 1892, quoted in Will Roscoe, The Zuni Man-Woman (University of New Mexico Press, 1991), 170. [source of third pull quote]
Matilda Coxe Stevenson, “The Zuni Indians: Their Mythology, Esoteric Societies, and Ceremonies,” in Twenty-Third Annual Report of the Bureau of American Ethnology to the Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, 1901–1902 (Government Printing Office, 1904). [source of second pull quote]
Sabine Lang, Men as Women, Women as Men: Changing Gender in Native American Cultures (University of Texas Press, 1998).
Will Roscoe, “The Zuni Man-Woman,” in OUT/LOOK: National Lesbian & Gay Quarterly (Summer 1988): 56–67. [source of first pull quote]
Will Roscoe, The Zuni Man-Woman (University of New Mexico Press, 1991).