Route 66 2SLGBTQ Historic Sites Project

Illustration by Ethan Brown
Note: For illustrative purposes only; actual details may vary

Witter Bynner & Robert Hunt Residence/Inn of the Turquoise Bear

Overview

The Inn of the Turquoise Bear, a gay-owned bed and breakfast open since 1996, occupies the former Santa Fe estate of the prolific 20th-century poet Witter Bynner and his lifelong partner, poet Robert Hunt.

Bynner and Hunt each lived there for over half their lives, transforming a single three-room cottage into a rambling 30-room estate that became a gathering place for major literary and artistic figures of the era.

Click images to enlarge and see captions.

History

While stopping in Santa Fe, New Mexico during a national lecture tour in 1922, the openly gay poet, translator, and professor Harold Witter “Hal” Bynner (1881-1968) fell ill, canceled the remainder of the tour, and decided to stay in Santa Fe permanently. His then-partner and secretary, the poet and publisher Walter Willard “Spud” Johnson (1897-1968), moved there with him.

Bynner rented an early 19th-century adobe cottage situated along the Old Santa Fe Trail (later part of the 1926-37 alignment of Route 66). After Bynner purchased the three-room cottage in 1925, he acquired adjacent buildings and constructed others to eventually form a rambling Spanish-Pueblo Revival style estate with 30 rooms. He landscaped the “bleak little yard,” adding flagstone walkways, steps, benches, and terraced retaining walls, and planting pine trees, cacti, lilac bushes, hollyhocks, pansies, azures, and more. The interior featured Bynner’s eclectic, impressive collection of Chinese paintings and carvings, Mexican curtains, Spanish santos sculptures, Native American jewelry and rugs, and 163 signed photographs of “faces of friends.”

In 1930, Bynner and the young poet Robert Nichols Hunt (1906-1964) became lifelong partners. Hunt moved into the house and lived there until his death, serving as Bynner’s business manager, editor, and, later, caretaker. Having briefly worked for his father, the prominent California-based architect Myron Hunt, he designed multiple additions to the estate.

Bynner and Hunt entertained various high-profile people in the arts at the estate, leading painter and printmaker Walter Cooper to deem it “the epicenter of Santa Fe’s cultural milieu” in Unbuttoned: Gay Life in the Santa Fe Arts Scene (2016). The extensive array of guests included Aldous Huxley, Ansel Adams, Carl Van Vechten, Christopher Isherwood, Clara Bow, D.H. Lawrence, Edna St. Vincent Millay (to whom Bynner was once engaged), Eleanor Roosevelt, Errol Flynn, Georgia O’Keeffe, Igor Stravinsky, J.B. Priestly, Lynn Riggs, Martha Graham, Mary Austin, Rita Hayworth, Robert Frost, Robert Oppenheimer, Stephen Spender, Thornton Wilder, New Mexico Senator Bronson Murray Cutting, W.H. Auden, Willa Cather, and Willard Nash.

Additionally, Bynner, Johnson, Riggs, Alice Corbin, and Haniel Long formed an informal poetry group for reading and appraising each other’s work. Calling it “The Rabble,” they met weekly, rotating the meeting location between each of their homes. It served as a forum where individuality was respected and where the poets could experiment and explore erotic themes. As Johnson explained,

“We could say whatever we liked and write whatever we liked and felt a very sympathetic understanding among the group.”

— Walter Willard “Spud” Johnson, 1968

Bynner wrote and published over a dozen books of poetry while living at the estate, including the incredibly popular The Way of Life According to Laotzu (1944) and Eden Tree (1931), his first and only work directly discussing his homosexuality. The poem was inspired by his former partner, Clifford McCarthy, and dedicated to Hunt. According to historian Jordan Biro Walters, “his reception within the national literary community declined after its publication probably because he had marked himself as a homosexual poet.” Hunt published only one collection, The Early World and Other Poems (1936), which he dedicated to Bynner.

A year after Hunt had a fatal heart attack at the estate in 1964, a severe stroke left Bynner homebound and under constant care. Upon Bynner’s death in 1968, he willed the estate to St. John’s College in Santa Fe, which used it as a residence hall until selling it in 1988. By the 1990s, the villa was deteriorating and, similar to much of Santa Fe’s historic fabric at the time, at risk of demolition to make way for a condominium complex. In 1996, Ralph L. Bolton II, an anthropologist and leading researcher in HIV/AIDS transmission, and his partner, Robert Frost, purchased the villa. After completing an award-winning restoration, they opened it as a 2SLGBTQ-friendly bed and breakfast called the Inn of the Turquoise Bear.

In 2014, gay couple Dan Clark and David Solem acquired the inn and have since continued its operation as a gay-owned bed and breakfast. Their stated goals as innkeepers and stewards are “to rekindle the comfort, creativity and hospitality for which this home was renowned in the past, to protect, restore and extend the legacy of its famous creator, and to provide our guests with a unique, restorative experience that captures the essence of Santa Fe’s past and present.”

Entry by Ethan Brown, project founder (August 2026)

Sources

Corinne P. Sze, “The Witter Bynner House,” Bulletin of the Historic Santa Fe Foundation 20, no. 2 (September 1992).

Ellen Threinen, “Don Gaspar Historic District,” National Register of Historic Places Nomination Form (US Department of the Interior, National Park Service, 1982), Section 8.

Jordan Biro Walters, “Uncommon Knowledge: A History of Queer New Mexico, 1920s-1980s,” PhD diss. (University of New Mexico, July 2015).

Ralph Bolton, “Applied Anthropology: A Way of Life, A Call to Action,” Human Organization 85, no. 1 (2026): 11-22.

Walter Cooper, Unbuttoned: Gay Life in the Santa Fe Arts Scene: A Memoir (self-published, CreateSpace, 2016).

Will Fellows, “Ralph Bolton and Robert Frost,” in manuscript for A Passion to Preserve: Gay Men as Keepers of Culture (University of Wisconsin Press, 2004), from Central Connecticut State University GLBTQ Archives, John Loughery Collection, 1934–2021, bit.ly/4oXWLJq.

Willard “Spud” Johnson, interview by Dr. Arrell Morgan Gibson, January 4, 1968, in Phyllis Cole Braunlich, Haunted by Home: The Life and Letters of Lynn Riggs (University of Oklahoma Press, 1988). [source of pull quote]

Witter Bynner, “A City of Change,” in Laughing Horse 11 (September 1924).

Witter Bynner Estate, Inn of the Turquoise Bear, bit.ly/4fxmaGY.